The answer to this question is that they are both compatible with each other, but it is recommended that you use the same brand of diapers as your child's current ones. This hasn't been a big deal for me. The author of this article does not accept any responsibility for any liability, loss or risk, personal or otherwise, incurred as a consequence, directly or indirectly, from any information or advice contained here. But I dont buy the armor hammer deodorizer because they get expensive. Unlike the Munchkin and the Diaper Genie, the Ubbi is made from steel and isnt porous. Childproof lock. I wasnt a fan of the diaper genie. I am looking for a diaper pail and the 3 that seem to come up most are the Munchkins step, UBBI and Diaper Genie. Still, the pail does a good job containing the smell otherwise. . Buy at Amazon Munchkin Step - Main Differences Capacity Closure Anti-microbial Odor-Absorbing Disks & Filters Special Bags Refill Rings Ease Of Use Safety Blade Material Cost Munchkin Step Review Munchkin Arm & Hammer Disks Odor Control Refill Bags Inserting Diapers Expense Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Review Opening The Lid Carbon Filters Refill Bags . Atone have a preference on a diaper pail? Reviewed's mission is to help you buy the best stuff and get the most out of what you already own. This article is NOT a substitute for medical advice. Others have foot pedals that allow you to do the work yourself. Diaper Genie II Elite, Diaper Genie Essentials and Diaper Genie II pails, Diaper Genie Expressions, and Diaper Genie Complete; Made with 7-layer film; Lavender-scented; error: We aim to show you accurate product information. Its not as gross as with the Munchkin pails, but there is a chance youll touch the pail itself, which isnt great. These bags are the cheapest option that I found. Others have foot pedals that allow you to do the work yourself. A Group Leader is a What to Expect community member who has been selected by our staff to help maintain a positive, supportive tone within a group. YES do this. Diaper Genie features bags made of 7-layers to minimize odor. Simply pull the front of the pail forward, cut the liner with the built-in blade, and tie the end. No one wants this to happen when you open a diaper pail, which is why Diaper Genie and Munchkin Step have both taken steps to eliminate the issue. For the ones that use special refill bags and the squeegee push method, you will most likely be greeted with a huge snake of soiled diapers contained within the bags. But to each their own. its one of those things that you dont need. the refills are expensive and so are the filters! Pictures of Munchkin Step belong to Munchkin brand. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. Create an account or log in to participate. Travel System Or Separate Car Seat And Stroller? Truthfully, no one wants a smelly nursery. Tell us a bit more about you so we can get to know each other better. When you lift the lid to put a new diaper in, you may get a little stinky sniff, but its not a big waft and goes away when the lid is down. Read some mixed reviews on both. The Diaper Genie Complete also includes the best odor fighter we tested. Learn more about, Twins & Multiples: Your Tentative Time Table, PLEASE give me your honest review Munchkin VS Diaper Genie. Bonus: For every pail purchased, Munchkin will plant a tree. Try it now. It's obvious that parents want to choose a pail that holds more diapers. Where the Dekor differs is the smell-trapping mechanism, which is basically a plastic trap door that you push the diapers past. It holds the smell in, cost less than $20, and is large enough that we only need to change it once or twice a week. Both pails have a built-in blade to cut off the liners at any length. Of course the amount of diaper that fits in the bag depends on the diaper size. We'll be in touch soon. Group Leaders communicate with staff moderators and escalate potential violations for review, but they dont moderate discussions. While both brands make excellent liners, not being able to use generic trash bags is a drawback. What I particularly like about the Arm and Hammer disks are that you can easily replace with baking soda from your own kitchen. It's the only pail out there that is stainless steel so it doesn't absorb the stink like the others that are plastic. Its not noticeable with a newborn or just one to two diapers, but when the bag is nearly full its impossible to escape. The only diaper pail compatible with both Refill Rings and Snap, Seal & Toss Bags. 11 kids' books about groundbreaking women for Women's How to Choose the Best Diaper Pail for You. >> Munchkin vs. But, if you have pets that get into the garbage, or live in a warm climate that would make the smell even worse when left outdoors, then a diaper pail might be especially useful! Diaper genie vs munchkin step diaper pail? Trying to choose between Diaper Genie vs Munchkin for disposing of your babys dirty diapers? Then, you can either buy a refill, or save money and use standard baking soda. Never had used a diaper pail with my toddler(would put them in disposable diaper bags) but when I became pregnant this time, I could not stand the smell of diapers(made me sick) so I got the munchkin one. . Step on the foot pedal, allow the lid to lift up and insert the soiled diaper through the gap in the center of the pail. Just open the lid, drop a dirty nappy in, close the lid, and the fouled garment gets released into the bagwithout you having to force it with your hand. Honestly, its a tough call. They also have a trap door in the front for easy diaper disposal. You need to push diapers through the Munchkins mechanism, but they should just fall through the flaps into the Genie. 0 Compare . Air dry and add carbon filters where possible. With 7 layers and a lavender scent, these bags are able to keep bad smells away. Heres how Diaper Genie and Munchkin Pail compare in terms of their features. The Expressions may look great with the designer sleeves, but its small, expensive to own, and requires you to force squishy diapers into it. A diaper pail is tightly concealed. We empty it out 1-2 times a week. Munchkin Fresh Diaper Pail Refills Price Comparison! The educational health content on What To Expect is reviewed by our medical review board and team of experts to be up-to-date and in line with the latest evidence-based medical information and accepted health guidelines, including the medically reviewed What to Expect books by Heidi Murkoff. And are certain models of one better than others? Seller 100% positive. One of the reasons is its superior odor control. Munchkin features a Patented self-sealing system that has made this pail the top choice for odor control. Considering I studied physics, engineering (PhD, MSc), I thoroughly research the topics I write about. It's much better than a standard trash can and way cheaper than pails that use special bags, but you'll have to live with a bit more stink. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. Copyright Proud Happy Mama PTY LTD 2023 | All Rights Reserved | PRIVACY|TERMS|DISCLOSURE | ACCESSIBILITY |CONTACT, Munchkin Arm & Hammer Puck Baking Soda Cartridge, Diaper Genie Bags Refills 270 (Pack of 3), Munchkin Diaper Pail Refill Rings (2 Pack), Baby Items Starting With A to Z Checklist. And if you love this guide on whats the difference between Diaper Genie and Munchkin diaper pails, then check out these guides on effective diaper pail deodorizer ideas and best diaper pail alternatives. My sister was plowing through disposables when she had a newborn baby and an 14-month old, and needed to empty her Diaper Genie every 3 days. In terms of odor prevention, this system is best, but it has a noticeable downside. What is better: Diaper Genie or Munchkin? This product is rated 4.3 stars out of 5 stars. Backed with a Masters Degree in Public Health, a Bachelor of Science in Health Promotion, a long career in health and safety, and 10 years of hands on experience using, researching, and testing baby products, I love to use my parenting experience to support and encourage other parents. Disposable Baby Diaper Sacks Diaper . While its initially more expensive than the Diaper Genie Complete, the design of this diaper pail will save you money in the long term because it uses regular trash bags instead of proprietary liner bagsmaking it our pick for Best Value: With trash bags costing about 10 cents per bag, you'll save upwards of $200 (or more) over the life of the pail. Parents love the Diaper Genie for convenience, and the Munchkin Step for excellent odor control. A Group Owner is a member that has initiated the creation of a group to connect with other members to share their journey through the same pregnancy & baby stages. ?Thanks in advanced! The Diaper Genie Expressions is just like the Diaper Genie Complete, but if you got rid of the things we liked and kept most of the things we didnt. And It holds quite a few days of diapers before you have to roll out more of the bag. But if you're using cloth diapers or you want to cut down on your monthly bills, the Ubbi is a great value that shouldn't be overlookedespecially when your kids are little and their diapers just don't smell that bad. Use the regular garbage bags. I agree. When you purchase all the Diaper Genie essentials like carbon filters and some refill bags, the cost will add up, but its still the cheaper option. When you think you are reaching bag capacity for your Munchkin pail, simply open the little door at the front, pull down the bag, cut it with the internal blade and tie it off. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As Ive mentioned before, both Munchkin and Diaper Genie are quality products thatll get the intended job done. Please select a reason for escalating this post to the WTE moderators: Connect with our community members by starting a discussion. Your post will be hidden and deleted by moderators. Keep Odors Away: 7-layer smell-bloc technology helps help trap odors . Additionally, both options have a step pedal which allows for easy hands-free operation. We are expecting baby #2 in June and were trying to . After that, rinse both the inside and outside of your diaper pail. Note that once you confirm, this action cannot be undone. Throw a dirty diaper in a normal trash can, and you might find the smell sticks around for a while. The Munchkin pail accepts two types of bags: the continuous liners or snap-close bags. Neither of these are very practical, which is why having a quality diaper pail that contains odors well is essential for new parents. Also, they recommend changing them out every 90 days, giving you more time than the carbon filters of the Playtex Diaper Genie Complete. Munchkin Step $64.75 960 Reviews Buy on Amazon Size 12.25 x 27.63 x 13 inches Material Plastic Hands-Free Yes Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail $24.95 - - Buy on Amazon Size 7 x 7 x 10 inches Material Plastic Hands-Free Yes Safety 1st Easy Saver Munchkin Arm & Hammer Bubula Steel Dekor Classic Hands-Free Akord Slim Adult Diaper Pail $21.12 $49.99 The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of What to Expect. $25. Group Leaders communicate with staff moderators and escalate potential violations for review, but they dont moderate discussions. 180 Diapers. Email us and we'll compare notes. Arm & Hammer 158 votes Ubbi Diaper Pail 18% 30 votes Diaper Genie (or elite) 25% 41 votes Arm & Hammer diaper pail 12% 20 votes I visit the garbage daily! Like pretty much all the pails out there, the Genie has a foot pedal and a trap door at the front. Another video for you guys! Bottom: Diaper Genie. I got the arm & hammer munchkin one for this baby and am super excited to try it!! Best Customizable Diaper Pail Playtex Diaper Genie Expressions. Plus, because of its proprietary refills, its long-term costs were the highest among our finalists. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a2e461abedcd3bf We respect everyones right to express their thoughts and opinions as long as they remain respectful of other community members, and meet What to Expects Terms of Use. Read More, It's not a bad design, but it doesn't contain smells as well as the Diaper Genie. On the one hand, its it an easy, one-handed operation to drop the dirty diaper into the pail. Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail, Fully Assembled, with Odor Lock Technology, Includes 1 Pail and 1 Refill, Grey Babies go through 9,600 diapers in 3 years . The Munchkin Step Pail has managed to do great in various roundups conducted by reviewers from highly trusted sources that . The Munchkin Step is slightly bigger than the Diaper Genie, but both have roughly the same capacity. The Diaper Genie is so popular that the name diaper genie has become synonymous with all diaper pails. Use of this site is subject to our terms of use and privacy policy. We're in the process of buying a new diaper pail. So fresh and so clean. Consult your doctor/pediatrician in case of any doubts. The Munchkin Step pail is tall and has an out of reach button for little fingers, but neither of these pails have a child lock. But, I like to try things out & form my own opinion. Munchkin pail here - my baby is 4 months old and there's been no smell or issues with the pail. All rights reserved. The Dekor Plus is also expensive to buy replacements for, with refills costing around $7 onlineif you buy them in bunches. We use exclusively for poop diapers, and while he is 22 months old and after they are on solids things change in a not pleasant way on that front, I feel like the odor lingers forever! The branded bags are expensive, and over time, this cost can really add up. I have the munchkin for my 2 year old (had since birth) I love it. When youre preparing for your little one, your to buy list might be considerably longer. that's a poop ton of diapers (pun intended). As long as you're diligent about changing the bag regularly, you shouldn't run into too many problems. Functionality Youve got a whole lot of poopy diapers right where your kiddo sleeps. Car Seats; Car Accessories For Baby; Travel Strollers; Baby Carriers . It has virtually become synonymous with the words diaper pail and with good reason. Diaper Genie. Our team of product experts thoroughly vet every product we recommend to help you cut through the clutter and find what you need. The Munchkin Step is a foot pedal operated diaper pail with a clever twist and seal method used to keep odors in. Both the Diaper Genie and the Munchkin Step are made of plastic, and can be easily wiped down should the need arise. Before you decide to buy one of these pails, I recommend you to check how much the accessories cost to be prepared for the long-term expense (check out Munchkin deodorizers & refills here). I found out that only these knockoff refills work with Munchkin. However, when it comes to overall user-friendliness, we think the Diaper Genie comes out on top. Ubbi is the one Ive liked the most of the 3 Ive used/had. Created by Playtex, the Diaper Genie is an easy-to-use pail with an excellent locking mechanism and a convenient foot pedal. But a particularly full diaper can cause a real issue. Are there alternatives? If youve narrowed down your choice to Playtex Diaper Genie Complete vs. Munchkin Step Diaper Pail, my comparison should help you make the final decision. Aside from making the changing process easier, it saves you from having to go out to the garbage bin at all hours of the night to dispose of dirty diapers. Both the Diaper Genie and the Munchkin work best with their own branded liners, but the initial cost of the Diaper Genie is typically less. If you want to save even more money, it may be a good idea to check out some DIY mom hacks for using these pails with regular plastic bags. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Munchkin UV Snap, Seal & Toss Diaper Pail Refill Bags - 20pk Munchkin 30 $19.79 When purchased online Buy 1 get 1 25% off diapering supplies Diaper Dekor Classic Diaper Pail Refills - 2pk Diaper Dekor 103 $11.99 When purchased online Munchkin Arm & Hammer Diaper Bag Refill Munchkin 244 $6.29 - $9.39 When purchased online Carbon filters and specially scented refill bags assist in masking odors. The convenient foot pedal makes the Diaper Genie very easy to use. Since plastic pails are often susceptible to retaining odors, its necessary to give any plastic pail a good wash with vinegar or baking soda from time to time. The snap-bags are more like trash bags, because you have to lift them up and out of the containers. Your post will be hidden and deleted by moderators. Investing in a quality diaper pail is one way to make things easier. You can use off-brand refill bags (more on that below), but for the Munchkin, if you use only its own-brand bags, the advantage is that they have baking soda-infused bags to help address the smell issue. Had it a week and threw it out! Hi I'm Allison! When the top is sealed, the air will not smell bad and you wont even notice you have a collection of dirty diapers in a pail. He is from the self-styled "Cranberry Capitol of the World," which is, in fact, a real thing. I just put a regular refresher and stick it in the pale. The Genie uses carbon filters that should be changed every 30 days, while the Munchkin has baking soda disks that are recommended to be switched out every 90 days. Im reading reviews but so confused. Sorry, but I see these odor-absorbing filters as more of a drawback than an advantage. Essentially, when you close the lid, the liner bag twists, sealing in smells. A great diaper pail will also have one-handed (or one-footed!) Beyond that, this is a sturdy standby that performs better than more expensive models and will help keep your nursery from smelling less than fresh. This article includes affiliate links to products that I think are useful for our readers. Free shipping. Both the Diaper Genie and the Munchkin Step recommend using their own branded liners with the diaper pail. It is a step-to-open design requiring only one hand for diaper deposits. Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer Awarded 2020 Best Overall Diaper Pail by the Good Housekeeping Institute Patented self-sealing system keeps odors contained whether lid is open or closed The only diaper pail compatible with both Refill Rings and Snap, Seal & Toss Bags $70.95 Buy on Amazon Your email address will not be published. Open a window or the front door on nice days to let fresh air into the house. The Diaper Genie is a cheaper system overall than the Munchkin Step. . While both pails are popular options, Ive found that the Munchkin has a few advantages that make it my personal favorite. Read reviews before buying anything other than the Munchkin brand bags. Many of the pails we checked out had at least one critical flaw. Weight: 12 pounds. Both diaper pails promise the end to bad smells in the nursery, but which performs best? Backed with a Masters Degree in Public Health, a Bachelor of Science in Health Promotion, a long career in health and safety, and 10 years of hands on experience using, researching, and testing baby products, Allison loves to use her parenting experience to support and encourage other parents. Diaper Genie refills are not compatible with Munchkin brand. Specs at a glance: Measures 14 x 12 x 24 inches Holds 30 newborn diapers Weighs 12 pounds Made of plastic Uses special Snap, Seal & Toss bags What We Love Patented self-sealing technology Comes with a starter refill ring and one Snap, Seal & Toss bag Baby Travel. 22% 35 votes I use something else. Dimensions: 12 x 28 x 13 inches. Other than the fact that at Babies R Us (at least) the genie is cheaper? It can be a little confusing when you first start using the Diaper Genie, but youll get used to it in no time. In this case, you can use regular garbage bags and dont fret over odor containment, because youre removing the smelly mess every day (or more frequently). Las mejores ofertas para 4 un. I find that the Diaper Genie Complete does a better job than a regular trash can, but, even when the lid isnt open, after a few months of use, the Diaper Genie has a constant unpleasant smell around it. Ideally, you want to place your pail as close to your changing table or changing pad on your dresser as possible. Also, the steel locks the stench in and doesn't absorb the smell like plastic containers. I have the munchkin one & its fine I guess but I wish Id gone with the Ubbi one instead. This design is actually very good at sealing in odor so it doesnt affect the roomthough when you empty the bag you're probably going to stink up the joint anyway. For . Theres no way to avoid the smell of dirt diapers altogether (if only! Pull a new bag through, tie a knot and start again. Final Decision: Is Munchkin Or Diaper Genie Better? Others allow you to use standard trash bags. A Group Owner is a member that has initiated the creation of a group to connect with other members to share their journey through the same pregnancy & baby stages. You dont have to try squeeze and extra full diaper into the pail and you can easily keep hold of your little one, without having to bend down. Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe Safety 1st Easy Saver Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe Diaper Dkor Plus. One Munchkin refill ring holds up to 272 diapers, and the Diaper Genie holds almost the same amount, up to 270. Theres no mess, and no fuss. Read More, If you're diligent in changing the bag, you shouldn't run into too many problems. This deodorizer works well, but it does need to be replaced roughly every 30 days. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Diaper Pail Refill Bags,Fully Compatible with Arm&Hammer Disposal System Seal. What to Expect supports Group Black and its mission to increase greater diversity in media voices and media ownership. They still smell. Group Leaders arent expected to spend any additional time in the community, and are not held to a set schedule. Your email address will not be published. How dirty diapers go in: Many diaper pails have a squeegee-style contraption that pushes diapers deep down to the bottom of the barrel. . When it comes to Munchkin vs Diaper Genie, two very popular brands, which one is better than the other? Does your favorite option require special bags? They arent super expensive, but a busy mom with a newborn doesnt need to be thinking about ordering something like carbon filters for a diaper pail. Specifications Dimensions (Overall): 24.0 Inches (H) x 14.0 Inches (W) x 12 Inches (D) Weight: 12 Pounds Features: Uses Standard Size Liners, Airtight Lid Prevents Odors Maximum capacity: 180 Diapers Material: Plastic Care & Cleaning: Spot or Wipe Clean Warranty: No Applicable Warranty. First, the Diaper Genie has a drop through lid, so you dont have to bend down to dispose of a dirty diaper. Arm & Hammer Diaper Pail Bag Refills - 20pk. How dirty diapers come out: If you have a diaper pail that is lined with a standard trash bag, its a no-brainer. Diaper Genie uses a drop through mechanism. Munchkin Step Diaper Pail A lot of parents already trust the Munchkin brand, so the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is another clear option as an alternative to the Diaper Genie. I've read both great & horrible things about it. The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of What to Expect. Baby Registries . The main difference between the two is the Munchkins self-sealing system, which really does a better job at odor control over the Diaper Genies folding slats. The whole reason to use a diaper pail instead of just a regular trash can is odor containment. You may also like UV Diaper Pail $129.99 STEP $73.99 Arm & Hammer Snap, Seal & Toss Diaper Pail Bag Refills $20.99 Arm & Hammer Diaper Pail Refill Rings $7.89 Toss Disposable Diaper Pail $4.19 Nursery Fresh Diaper Pail Refills $5.49 Second, the Diaper Genie has a front tilt bin. 195.154.38.27 When it comes to shortlisting your favorite option, its important to know the key differences. Made from steel and powder coated so easy to maintain. Last update on 2023-03-04 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Each one uses an additional accessory in the lid to help stop the stink. . The Diaper Genie Expressions was not one of our favorite diaper pails. But with heavily soiled, squishy diapers, you're going to have to shove them into the bag. Arm & Hammer Diaper Pail Snap, Seal and Toss Refill Bags. If youre open to other suggestions, Ive used a dekor for the last 2 years & love it. Allison Banfield an experience mom of two, wife, writer, editor, and passionate parenting advocate! Offers Superior odor protection Made with 7-layer odor-barrier film Each diaper ring holds up to 272 newborn diapers Fits ALL Diaper Genie Elite, Complete, Elite, Essentials and "Mini" Pails. Same here. If it doesnt drop down right away, just use the step lever a few times to make the diaper fall down. The Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail, however, while a very good choice in its own right, falls just a bit short of being remarkable. Check Price. You almost always wind up touching the bag, which has already touched at least one other dirty diaper. The smell briefly escapes (disappears in minutes) when you open it if its full of poopy diapers. While the odor locking properties are excellent, the tight opening can make diaper disposal a little tricky. Diaper Genie is one of the best known names in diaper pails, and many moms have relied on their Diaper Genie to make the nursery a more pleasant place to play. I could care less about some poop on my hands, but that's a nuisance when you have a squirmy kid on a changing table and you're trying to get them dressed again. While the tall build of the Munchkin Step means you dont have to bend far, pushing the diaper through the lid might put some strain on a new moms back! In this article youll find my diaper pail reviews, based on my own experience. We spent many hours on research to finding munchkin vs diaper genie, reading product features, product specifications for this guide. Realistically, youll need to empty the diaper pail every few days (at least). You may find yourself ready to toss bags out before they are at capacity because the room is smelling of dirty diapers. I had a diaper genie many years ago for cleaning the cat box, and I remember it working well. when i. An out-of-reach lock prevents little children from causing big disasters. Both the Munchkin and Diaper Genie are made from sturdy plastic. Are you one of those parents looking for the best diaper pail and hesitating between Diaper Genie versus Munchkin Step? Whilst the Munchkin Step wins on odor control, the Diaper Genie is more than effective at controlling odors.